Which Way Home

* This doc is temporarily available to view on CBC’s Passionate Eye website here.*

I missed Which Way Home when it screened at the Tribeca Film Festival last Spring when I was in New York, so I was happy that it turned up at Hot Docs in Toronto a week later. I had a hunch that this film would move me.

I didn’t know anything about it beyond it’s description in the Tribeca FF catalogue, something about migrant children from Central America who, largely indepedently from their parents and families, make the fateful decision to migrate illegally through Mexico and into the United States. Many of them fail along the way – they are abducted, they injure themselves, they run of of funds and call home for help. Some of them die.

The bulk of the film is spent on the trains that cross Mexico where we were exposed to expansive shots of lush and dreamy landscape. We encountered several well-rounded characters like 14-year old Kevin, full of hope for a life and career in Manhattan, and nine-year old friends Olga and Freddy who hope to reunite with parents in the United States.

These children, we hoped as we watched, the filmmaker would be able to reassure us made it to safety… but Director Rebecca Cammisa told her Hot Docs audience that sadly, their fate remains unknown. 

It’s an anguish for documentary filmmakers, who’s job is to witness and record an event with the purpose of communicating that event with an audience, to have to let go of the subject.

But there is a point when filmmakers must draw a line. For the directors of Which Way Home (Cammisa hired additional camera-people) the line was drawn somewhere approaching the Mexico/U.S. border where bandits and smugglers too often act with ruthless violence.

At this point the filmmakers stopped following the children because they decided it was too dangerous for them – for them! They who were traveling with health insurance and passports – not to mention sheer adult physicality.

Don’t get me wrong, this is not a criticism. I can only imagine how heart-wrenching it must have been to film these beautiful, hopeful and spirited children as they embark on what they imagine is their journey to a better life, when in reality most never make it safely to the U.S. They are caught at the border and sent to jail-like detention centres before being shipped right back where they came from. Or they suffocate in the trunks of smugglers cars. Or worse.

Yet Which Way Home is a testament to a child’s huge stores of hope and courage while it puts a face on the realities of illegal immigration.

Which Way Home airs on CBC News Network Sunday January 24th at 10 PM ET/PT. Click here for details.

For more:

NPR interview with director Rebecca Cammisa including transcript.

Advertisements

One response to “Which Way Home

  1. Though the American/Mexican border and US Immigration are systems are severely broken and inhumane, I despair at the effects of neglect no matter where you live. The film was clearly making the statement that the border is deadly and asks US/Mexico to look at their policies. But is anyone asking the questions about why some of the children who are not going “to” the US as much as they are running “from” their homes? The hearts of some these children (like Kevin) are irreperably broken from emotional neglect and abuse and it is surprising that only one of them is an addict at the end of the film. The loss of potential is palpable, but I feel that we are avoiding the discussion about the need for social service support for domestic violence and child neglect which enable people to find a way to belong and contribute in their own communities (Canada included). I think that the film makers have opened the door on child abuse/neglect by showing the communities the kids come from, but it has been overlooked in the discussions.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s